Exterior front with covered entry
$645,000 | 62 Mystic Circle, Islip, NY 11706 | 3 Bed, 3 Bath | Listing by Herrick Real Estate LLC

Mystic Woods Community

home_pin Mystic Cir, Bay Shore, NY 11706 | Suffolk, NY county

Mystic Woods is a welcoming townhouse community located in the heart of Bay Shore, offering a relaxed and neighborly atmosphere paired with everyday convenience. Developed between 1989 and 1992, this intimate community of about 70 homes is known for its mature landscaping, quiet streets, and a true sense of pride in ownership. Thoughtfully designed and beautifully maintained, Mystic Woods feels established, comfortable, and easy to call home.

The community features a mix of two- and three-bedroom townhomes, most arranged over two levels with full basements, as well as a desirable ranch-style model that provides easy one-floor living. Homes are generously sized, ranging from roughly 1,900 to nearly 2,600 square feet, and many offer open layouts with cathedral ceilings, fireplaces, central air conditioning, in-unit laundry, private patios, and attached one- or two-car garages. The variety of floor plans allows residents to find a home that suits both their lifestyle and long-term needs.

Mystic Woods is ideally positioned near shopping, dining, beaches, and major roadways, while remaining quietly residential. It sits alongside the neighboring Mystic Oaks and Mystic Pines communities, creating a cohesive and attractive residential enclave within Bay Shore.

Mystic Woods offers the best of both worlds: a peaceful, well-kept community with strong neighborhood spirit, and a prime South Shore location that keeps residents connected to recreation, culture, and everyday conveniences.

measuring_tape
7,864 sq.ft. Average Lot Size
ad
0 Active Listings
source_environment
71 Total Housing Units
square_foot
1,906 Average Square Footage

Resident Amenities

pool Pool
water_lux Pond
sports_tennis Tennis Court
family_group Clubhouse

Schedule a visit

Select when you would like to go to visit.

What time?

or

Schedule a visit

Select when you would like to go to visit.

What time?

or

Resident Amenities

expand_less
pool Pool
water_lux Pond
sports_tennis Tennis Court
family_group Clubhouse

Interactive Map

Mystic Woods Community (and nearby)
For Sale
For Rent
In Contract
Sold Last Year
Sold Last 3 Years
Sold Last 5 Years

Mystic Woods Residences

Data loading...

Active Listings & Homes For Sale and For Rent

Photo Lot Price Beds Baths Square Feet HOA Fees
Loading listings data...
Loading listings data...

Not Finding a Perfect Fit?

Explore more homes for sale in Bay Shore.

Search More Homes

Recent Activity at The Mystic Woods Community

Date Lot Status
Loading activity data...
Loading activity data...

Floorplans

Loading floorplans…
Loading floorplans…

Community Facts

  • Community Name: Mystic Woods
  • Neighborhood: Bay Shore
  • Year Established: 1989
  • Total Homes: 71 residences
  • Property Type: Townhomes
  • County: Suffolk, NY county
  • Available Sales Listings: 0
  • Available Rental Listings: 0
  • Lifestyle & HOA: Life at Mystic Woods is centered around comfort, connection, and ease. The homeowners association is actively involved and managed by a dedicated volunteer board, ensuring that the community remains beautifully cared for and enjoyable for all residents. Landscaping, common areas, and shared amenities are thoughtfully maintained, allowing homeowners to enjoy a low-maintenance lifestyle without sacrificing space or quality of living. The clubhouse serves as a social focal point for the community, hosting gatherings and activities that bring neighbors together throughout the year. Residents enjoy access to a heated outdoor swimming pool, as well as tennis and pickleball courts, perfect for both casual recreation and staying active. A peaceful pond adds to the community’s charm, creating a calming backdrop for daily walks and quiet moments outdoors. Mystic Woods is also pet-friendly, adding to its warm, inclusive feel. Beyond the gates, residents benefit from everything Bay Shore has to offer. The Great South Bay is just minutes away, with nearby beaches, marinas, and waterfront parks providing endless opportunities for boating, swimming, and outdoor fun. Fire Island’s ocean beaches are a short drive away, while golf courses, country clubs, and town parks surround the area. Bay Shore’s vibrant Main Street only a few minutes from home, offers an array of restaurants, boutiques, cultural venues, and year-round community events, from festivals and concerts to farmers markets and parades.

Frequently Asked Questions

Learn more about the Mystic Woods community and available homes for sale and rent here in Bay Shore.

add When was Mystic Woods built?
Mystic Woods was built in 1989.
add Where is Mystic Woods located?
Mystic Woods is located at Mystic Cir in Bay Shore in NY.
add What amenities does the Mystic Woods community provide?
Mystic Woods provides the following resident amenities: Pool, Pond, Tennis Court, Clubhouse.
add What county is Mystic Woods located in?
Mystic Woods is located in Suffolk, NY county.
add How many homes are currently available in Mystic Woods for sale or for rent?
Out of 71 homes in Mystic Woods, there are currently 0 sales listings and 0 rental listings available.
add What is the average square footage in the Mystic Woods community?
The average square footage of homes in Mystic Woods is 1905 sq.ft.
add How big is the Mystic Woods community?
The Mystic Woods community is made up of 71 homes with an average lot size of 7864 sq.ft.

Nearby Similar Communities

Bay Shore, NY Mystic Oaks 70 Homes
Bay Shore, NY Mystic Pines 91 Homes
Bay Shore, NY Sunscape 63 Homes
Bay Shore, NY The Amiralty 93 Homes
Bay Shore, NY Cortland Square 40 Homes
North Babylon, NY Woods Edge 110 Homes
East Islip, NY The Moorings 89 Homes
Central Islip, NY Courthouse Commons 255 Homes
Dix Hills, NY Stone Ridge Estates 108 Homes
Central Islip, NY Islip Landing 223 Homes
Central Islip, NY Foxgate at Islip 143 Homes

Schedule a Visit

By clicking send, you accept the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, and understand you will be contacted by Highline Residential via email, phone call, and/or text message to discuss prospective opportunities.

Ask a Question

By clicking send, you accept the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, and understand you will be contacted by Highline Residential via email, phone call, and/or text message to discuss prospective opportunities.

Join Waitlist

By clicking send, you accept the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, and understand you will be contacted by Highline Residential via email, phone call, and/or text message to discuss prospective opportunities.

Sign up to get community updates

Subscribe to property updates

By clicking send, you accept the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, and understand you will be contacted by Highline Residential via email, phone call, and/or text message to discuss prospective opportunities.

Sign up to join the waitlist!

Subscribe to property updates

By clicking send, you accept the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, and understand you will be contacted by Highline Residential via email, phone call, and/or text message to discuss prospective opportunities.

Floorplan